I bought a fixer in 2009. The place leaked like crazy near the skylights. I had it fixed once through a personal referral and the leaks returned a year later. I found Gary on Craig's list. When I first met him, I was a little concerned because the guy was totally scruffed out with long hair and a beard. However, I allowed him to examine the roof and realized he new what he was talking about and address all the problems I knew existed. I paid him to fix the flashing of the skylights. After the first major rain fall, the roof was still leaking in one portion of the house. I realized this was not the flashings we agreed upon but another part of the roof. Gary agreed to return and fixed the problem by full re-tiling around the skylight. We agreed that I would just pay him extra for the material he used. I think he was incredibly fair and took responsibility for his work, even when the extra work was not part of the initial agreement. I would hire this guy, don't let his scruffy looks full you. This guys is good and fair. - Dave Mudd