The Number One Hardware Store in New Milford, PA Tired of 'big box' retailers who just don't get it? We are too! At New Milford Hardware we are passionate about our customers. From the moment you walk in our front door, you'll know it. We are a fully stocked hardware store, carrying everything from lumber and electrical supplies to fixtures and plumbing supplies. We take pride in serving builders and consumers in the New Milford, PA area and we would love the chance to earn your business. You deserve the New Milford Hardware experience!